When you buy through links on this site, I may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.

Brother ST531HD vs. Singer 4423 Comparison

If you are looking for comparisons between Brother ST531HD and Singer 4423, you’re at the right place. Which sewing machine is the right choice for you? They’re both solidly built and would be a fantastic machine for anyone who loves to sew.

What are the main differences between them? Allow me to simplify my answers here.

Brother ST531HD vs. Singer 4423: Comparison in Features

Sewing Machine Types

Brother ST531HD and Singer 4423 are both mechanical sewing machines. The mechanical sewing machine has fewer stitch options than a computerized sewing machine, but it is easier to maintain and costs less.

Brother ST531HD vs. Singer 4423 : Built-in Stitches

The Brother ST531HD sewing machine comes with an attractive amount of built-in stitches, 53 to be exact. Within those 53 stitches you can find standard stitches, decorative stitches and easy-to-use buttonhole stitches. While the Singer 4423 features 23 stitches. Similar to the Brother ST531HD, these stitches include standard and decorative stitches.

Weight

The Brother ST531HD sewing machine weighs approximately 14.3 lbs, while the Singer 4423 sewing machine comes with a weight of 14.5 lbs.

When you don’t have a specific spot in your home where your sewing machine belongs, the extra weight can become burdensome.

Start/Stop Button

Neither Brother ST531HD nor Singer 4423 sewing machine has a start/stop button. This might not be convenient for a novice to sew effectively.

Speed Control Slider

Neither Brother ST531HD sewing machine nor Singer 4423 sewing machine has a speed control slider. With a speed control slider, the sewing speed will never go above your selected speed, no matter how hard you press on the pedal.

Automatic Needle Threader

Many sewing machines sold today come with an automatic threader function. This is essentially a lever that will guide the thread through the eye of your sewing needle for you so that you don’t have to do it yourself. Many sewists prefer to thread their own needles, but if you have difficulty performing this task, then a machine with an automatic needle threader might be very useful for you. Fortunately, these two sewing machines both come with automatic needle threader, allowing you to thread the machine with ease.

Drop-in Bobbin

The advantage of easy drop-in, top load bobbins is that you can readily see how much thread is left on the bobbin through the window. You do not have to remove the bobbin case to insert a new bobbin, and you do not have to remove the accessory tray from the free arm to change bobbins. Both the Brother ST531HD and the Singer 4423 sewing machine come with this user-friendly feature.

Programmable Needle Up/Down

With a programmable needle up/down function, the needle will stop down in the fabric, allowing you to raise the presser foot and adjust the fabric without the fabric moving out of position because the needle will hold the fabric in place. However, unfortunately, these two sewing machines come with this feature.

Drop Feed

The most common type of feeding mechanism in a home sewing machine (and some industrial machines) is the drop feed, also known as the regular feed system. Both Brother ST531HD and Singer 4423 come equipped with a drop feed system, which grabs the fabric and moves it along through the machine.

Free Arm

There is free arm on both the Brother ST531HD and the Singer 4423. The free arm is a very useful feature to all sewing machines as it makes sewing one layer of fabric without catching another. This is because all of the workings around the bobbin race, feed dogs, and needles are housed there.

Brother ST531HD Singer 4423
Product Image
Sewing Machine Type Mechanical Mechanical
Stitches 53 23
Buttonhole Styles 1 one-step 1 one-step
Start/Stop Button No No
Built-in Memory No No
Programmable Needle Up/Down No No
Monogramming Font No No
Drop Feed Yes Yes
Free Arm Yes Yes
Working Light Yes 1 LED
Speed Control Slider No No
Weight 14.3 lbs 14.5 lbs
Extra High Presser Foot Lifter Yes
Snap-on Presser Foot Yes Yes
Automatic Thread Cutter No No
Automatic Needle Threader Yes Yes
Drop-in Bobbin Yes Yes
USB Connectivity No No
Stitch Selection Dial on Side Dial
Adjustable Stitch Length/Width Yes Yes
Included Feet Buttonhole foot, Button sewing foot, Spring action zigzag foot, Zipper foot, Non stick foot, Blind stitch foot. All-Purpose Foot, Zipper Foot, Buttonhole Foot, Button Sewing Foot
Dedicated Locking Stitch Button No No
Tension Adjustable With Dial Adjustable With Dial
Knee Lifter No No
Warranty 25 Year Limited 25 Year Limited
Price Check Price on Amazon Check Price on Amazon

Brother ST531HD Video Review

Singer 4423 Video Review

The Verdict

Both of these sewing machines come from fantastic companies, but they are particularly difficult to choose between. Based on their features, my overall recommendation would be to choose the machine that comes with more built-in stitches at an affordable price.

Q. What type of maintenance do sewing machines need?

A. Today’s sewing machines usually require just a few basic steps to keep them in good working order. While the manual included with your machine will spell out the details, it’s important to regularly remove the throat plate and use a small, soft brush to remove thread, lint, and debris that might have become lodged inside the machine. Your machine may also require oiling to keep everything lubricated and running smoothly.

Q. Can I interchange metal and plastic bobbins if they are the same size?

A. Metal bobbins and plastic bobbins of the same size can NOT be swapped. Machines are set for a very precise tension setting. If they are set for a lighter plastic bobbin, the tension will change if a heavier metal bobbin is used.

Q. Can i use serger thread in my sewing machine

A. Do not use serger thread in your sewing machine. These spools of thread are tempting to buy because they’re inexpensive, but they have a very rough texture on the thread. So if you put it in your regular sewing machine, it’s going to break and jam and you’ll be really frustrated.

Q. Why use a walking foot on a sewing machine

A. A walking foot helps move knit fabrics evenly so they don’t stretch out of shape. The walking foot eliminates the need for excessive pinning when working with slippery fabrics. That is especially useful because most of those slippery fabrics, such as satin, are easily damaged by pins.

Q. What should I know about manual vs. electric sewing machines?

A. Manual sewing machines were the mainstay of the crafting world, but in more recent years electric (also known as computerized) machines have been increasing in popularity for their easy operation and advanced functions, such as embroidery.

If you’re looking for a simple sewing experience without frills, a mechanical machine gives you straightforward functionality.

Without electronic components, some feel that these machines prove more reliable in the long term.

However, computerized machines may shorten the learning curve for some new sewers, since choosing stitches and settings only requires the push of a button.

Q. Can i use clipper oil on my sewing machine

A. Yes, you can as some people do recommend it as an alternative to sewing machine oil.