Oliveborden.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on this site, I may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more.

Singer 44S vs. Singer XL-420 Comparison

In this comparison, we are going to compare one of the most popular affordable sewing machines, the Singer 44S and Singer XL-420. What made these two sewing machines stand out was that they were packed with features in an affordable range combined with excellent stitch quality.

What are the major differences between them? Here I will try to answer them as simply as possible.

Singer 44S vs. Singer XL-420: Comparison in Features

Sewing Machine Types

The Singer 44S is a mechanical sewing machine, while the Singer XL-420 is a sewing and embroidery combo machine. Since the machine types decide they differ a lot in features, I won’t make a suggestion.

Choose wisely depends on your sewing goal and skill levels.

Singer 44S vs. Singer XL-420 : Built-in Stitches

The Singer 44S has 23 stitches. The Singer XL-420 on the other hand comes with 30 built-in stitches. The apparent difference is in the buttonhole styles, where Singer 44S sewing machine comes with 1 one-step buttonhole(s), Singer XL-420 has only 2 one-step buttonhole(s).

Weight

The Singer 44S sewing machine weighs approximately 17 lbs, while the Singer XL-420 comes with a weight of 25 lbs.

When you don’t have a specific spot in your home where your sewing machine belongs, the extra weight can become burdensome.

Start/Stop Button

The Singer 44S doesn’t come with a start/stop button, while the Singer XL-420 sewing machine does. One of the best ways of controlling some of your variables within free motion quilting is by using your start/stop button.

Speed Control Slider

The Singer XL-420 sewing machine arrives with a speed control slider while the Singer 44S doesn’t. A speed control slide is a useful feature that allows you to set the maximum speed you are comfortable with.

Automatic Needle Threader

Many sewing machines sold today come with an automatic threader function. This is essentially a lever that will guide the thread through the eye of your sewing needle for you so that you don’t have to do it yourself. Many sewists prefer to thread their own needles, but if you have difficulty performing this task, then a machine with an automatic needle threader might be very useful for you. Fortunately, these two sewing machines both come with automatic needle threader, allowing you to thread the machine with ease.

Drop-in Bobbin

The advantage of easy drop-in, top load bobbins is that you can readily see how much thread is left on the bobbin through the window. You do not have to remove the bobbin case to insert a new bobbin, and you do not have to remove the accessory tray from the free arm to change bobbins. Both the Singer 44S and the Singer XL-420 sewing machine come with this user-friendly feature.

Drop Feed

The most common type of feeding mechanism in a home sewing machine (and some industrial machines) is the drop feed, also known as the regular feed system. Both Singer 44S and Singer XL-420 come equipped with a drop feed system, which grabs the fabric and moves it along through the machine.

Extra High Presser Foot Lifter

The extra-high presser foot lifter of the Singer 44S and Singer XL-420 allows you to adjust the height, as needed for large sewing projects or multiple layers of thick materials.

Singer 44S Singer XL-420
Product Image
Sewing Machine Type Mechanical Sewing and Embroidery Combo
Stitches 23 30
Buttonhole Styles 1 one-step 2 one-step
Start/Stop Button No Yes
Built-in Memory
Programmable Needle Up/Down No Yes
Monogramming Font No Yes, 5
Drop Feed Yes Yes
Free Arm Yes
Working Light Yes Yes, 6 LEDs
Speed Control Slider No Yes
Weight 17 lbs 25 lbs
Extra High Presser Foot Lifter Yes Yes
Snap-on Presser Foot Yes
Automatic Thread Cutter No No
Automatic Needle Threader Yes Yes
Drop-in Bobbin Yes Yes
USB Connectivity Yes
Stitch Selection Dial Push Button
Adjustable Stitch Length/Width Yes
Included Feet Embroidery Foot, All Purpose Foot, Zipper Foot, Buttonhole Foot with Underplate, Blind Hem Foot, Satin Stitch Foot, Button Sewing Foot
Dedicated Locking Stitch Button
Tension Adjustable With Dial Automatic Tension
Knee Lifter Yes
Warranty 25 Year Limited
Price Check Price on Amazon Check Price on Amazon

Singer 44S Video Review

Singer XL-420 Video Review

The Verdict

The Singer 44S and the Singer XL-420 have a number of differences in terms of features. The stitch quality, however, is a common aspect. These two machines sew on a range of materials with reliable results. Any of these two machines would be my first choice if you asked me to choose an affordable, sophisticated sewing machine. I won’t offer a recommendation and the choice should be based on your sewing ability and experience.

Q. Why use a walking foot on a sewing machine

A. A walking foot helps move knit fabrics evenly so they don’t stretch out of shape. The walking foot eliminates the need for excessive pinning when working with slippery fabrics. That is especially useful because most of those slippery fabrics, such as satin, are easily damaged by pins.

Q. What should I know about manual vs. electric sewing machines?

A. Manual sewing machines were the mainstay of the crafting world, but in more recent years electric (also known as computerized) machines have been increasing in popularity for their easy operation and advanced functions, such as embroidery.

If you’re looking for a simple sewing experience without frills, a mechanical machine gives you straightforward functionality.

Without electronic components, some feel that these machines prove more reliable in the long term.

However, computerized machines may shorten the learning curve for some new sewers, since choosing stitches and settings only requires the push of a button.

Q. Does the machine work well with stretchy materials?

A. The machine works perfectly with all types of fabrics. As long as the user can work with the material, there should be no problem.

Q. Do you need a special sewing machine for leather?

A. No, although a heavy-duty machine will make it easier. However, any good-quality home sewing machine can handle leather with a few special accessories. You will need a Teflon presser foot, a needle designed for sewing leather, and heavy-duty thread.

Q. How do I thread a sewing machine?

To get started with your sewing project, you’ll need to first thread your sewing machine. While your machine’s manual should guide you in the specific sequence for your make and model, the basic process starts by placing the presser foot in the up position.

Next, put your thread spool on the spool holder and bring the thread across the top of the machine, through the thread guide. Insert the thread through the tension mechanism, sliding it between the metal disks before pulling it back upwards. Find the take-up lever and place the thread into the hole. Pull the thread towards the sewing machine needle, using available thread guides as you go.

Finally, bring the needle into an accessible position by adjusting the handwheel. Insert the thread. Your sewing machine should be threaded and ready to go, but it’s always a good idea to make a test run on a sample swatch to check your work.

However, if you sewing machine comes with an automatic needle threader, that would save you lots of time.

Q. What are features to look for in a sewing machine?

A. The best features will depend on the type of sewing you plan to do. For a beginner, some features to look for include built-in stitch types, an automatic needle threader, a top drop-in bobbin, and a set of standard presser feet.